Equity in Athletics, Inc., v. Department of Education and James Madison University, et al., March 8, 2011

Flickr User: s_falkow Flickr User: s_falkow

 

Content Summary

The Women’s Sports Foundation reprints this unanimous opinion by the 4th Circuit with our highlights, which affirms the dismissal of the litigation at the earliest stage of litigation. The case was brought by an anti-Title IX group that was attempting to weaken the law. The appellate panel rejected all the claims by the group, Equity in Athletics Inc.. The court held that the university's actions, when it substantially decreased the size of its athletic department for men and women, were constitutional and conformed with federal law. The court specifically upheld the 1979 3-part test as not being a quota and promulgated improperly. The 4th Circuit noted the unanimity of the law as applied to athletics across the country. The same legal reasoning is now being used to try to Title IX in the high school context, and will likely receive similar treatment.

EQUITY IN ATHLETICS v. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION and JAMES MADISON UNIVERSITY, et al. (PDF 272k)

Download Now

Published Aug 3, 2011
By Women's Sports Foundation

EXPLORE FURTHER

Katie Thomas NY Times Article, At Two-Year Colleges, Less Scrutiny

The New York Times’ article, At Two-Year Colleges, Less Scrutiny Equals Less Athletic Equality, emphasizes the importance of Title IX oversight, and the ongoing importance of the laws themselves. Sports opportunities at Community Colleges are rare educational opportunities, subsidized with our tax dollars, delivering superior life-long returns on investment.

Male Practice Players on Female Teams

The regular use of male practice players may take practice and participation opportunities away from female athletes on varsity teams. Did you know that the regular use of male practice players may be a Title IX violation?

Participation of Intersex Athletes in Women's Sports

Intersex athletes are vulnerable to exclusion from women’s sports, as well as ridicule and invasion of privacy. We believe that women with intersex conditions have the same rights to participation in athletics as all women.

STAY IN-THE-KNOW

Sign up for our newsletter to receive infrequent updates, news and information.

SUBSCRIBE